Where to find it: Netflix
Length: 134 minutes
Synopsis: “Give it a rest, Charlie Kaufman, some of us have work in the morning, damn!”
Recommendation rating: 3/5
What I like about it: Jessie Buckley, the writing (sometimes), themes connected hard with me
What I don’t like about it: almost indecipherable, lost entirely up its own arse
Review:
You know how sometimes an internet movie review will say something like, “This is a really good movie when you watch it the second to twelfth time!”? Well I’m gonna try to save that first painful nonsense viewing for you by providing some context upfront, even though it’ll spoil the ‘reveals’ along the way. If you really want to go in knowing nothing – I assume you have time for the extra rewatches – this is not the review for you.
Most of the film consists of a young woman going to meet her boyfriend’s parents even though she’s unsure about the relationship. As is typical for Kaufman, strange things happen and get increasingly surreal as it goes; for instance the young woman doesn’t seem to have a name or occupation that sticks for more than ten minutes before being changed without any acknowledgement from the characters. The main story is inexplicably intercut with scenes of a quiet janitor cleaning a high school. By the end of the story, we learn that the janitor is an older version of the boyfriend and the only ‘real’ part of the whole film – the story that takes up most of the movie is in fact him daydreaming about what life would have been like if he had ever actually talked to a woman.
If you’ve ever seen one of these before (Being John Malkovich; Synechdoche, New York; Anomalisa) you’ll understand the kind of pretentious surreal symbolism you’re in for if you take this one on. Has a 4:3 aspect ratio, characters quoting poetry at each other and an extended Rogers & Hammerstein dream ballet. But if you can tolerate all this, it makes more sense than most of his back catalogue, possibly due to being an adaptation. Has a far better treatment of the Manic Pixie Dream Girl trope than his earlier Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
Content notes (may contain spoilers): suicide, relationship trouble, sudden loud bell sounds, the “autistic guys die alone” trope