Where to find it: NowTV
Length: Six 40-minute episodes
Synopsis: Nathan Fielder wastes HBO’s money, traumatises a child
Recommendation rating: 4/5
What I like about it: absurd humour, smart, a great idea
What I don’t like about it: not quite as good in execution, poorly paced, i’m absolutely furious at him
Review:
Nathan Fielder’s latest project finds him exploring such worthy and neurodivergent-adjacent themes as scripting/rehearsal, fear of social mistakes and empathy. He sets up a format in the first episode of finding a person who has been putting off something difficult and running them through the possibilities in a comically high-budget simulation. This is a (seemingly planned) misdirect however and the second rehearsal project gets Nathan’s personal attention and gets way out of control.
If you’ve seen Nathan For You and know his style, you’ll find plenty here to enjoy. He sets up awkwardness and absurdity that are very funny and the mix of simulation and real life is interesting, though far less subversive in this series as his targets move away from the world of business. The funniest moments in this are when Nathan, having chosen Evangelicals and Punisher tattoo guys for his show, is shocked to encounter anti-Semitism and breaks his usual deadpan character to deal with them, pranking one of them so hard that he drops out of the show. The rehearsals he sets up are soon shown to be inadequate and he tries to fix this by ‘going deeper’ and trying to make them perfect, using HBO’s infamous creative generosity to show how no amount of preparation can truly prepare someone for interacting with another person.
The final episode is both the best and worst of the series, it gave me extremely mixed feelings about the whole project which are at least mirrored by Fielder. As part of one of his staged rehearsals, he bonded with a fatherless and developmentally-delayed six-year-old, Remy, who became confused and very upset at losing Nathan when he wrapped on the show. I have no idea how this show was meant to end but this gave him a pretty much perfect ending, albeit a very exploitative and inconsiderate one. Having made a huge mistake while trying to avoid making mistakes, Nathan culminates by examining this and concluding that empathy – while flawed – is a worthwhile pursuit and that rehearsing to avoid living is not.
It hit me so hard I have to give this show a good rating but he owes the entire project, and frankly any remuneration from it, to Remy and his mother. Fielder says at the end, in a speech that may as well be to his vulnerable inner child, “It’s not bad to make mistakes, because it shows you have a heart.” He certainly does have a heart, but his heart and his brain need to talk more. This is a very clever project marred by an inexcusable choice to spend too much money on sets, crew and cast while spending none on having a child psychologist on set.
Content notes (may contain spoilers): simulated overdose, very upset child